Aligning the Trifocal Value-driven Viewpoints Inside Every Organization
MoneyMoz.com presents you “Aligning the Trifocal Value-driven Viewpoints Inside Every Organization”, an article written by Jidé Odubiyi. We hope you’ll find a lot useful information in here.
MoneyMoz.com will present you every article we find interesting and educating, and which has no copyright protection. If available we’ll link the source.
The three cultures inside every organization are analogous to the story of the three blind mice and the elephant. The perspective of each mouse is framed by the part of the elephant it touches. It was almost a decade ago when Schein (1996) wrote about the three cultures of management. He asserts that there are three communities in organizational setting— executives, engineers, and operators—and they do not fully understand each other. In Shein’s view, when the three communities are not aligned, their actions limit organizational learning.
Schein defines the management culture as a set of basic tacit assumptions shared by a group of people. These assumptions color the way they perceive, think, feel, and behave. His tripartite conception of this culture is similar to Stephen Covey’s (1991) discussion of how individuals’ value judgments affect interpersonal relationships. The first way is when people interact at the deep value-based level that forms the core of the group. The second is when the group tries to convey a public image. The third involves the way the group actually operates on a day-to-day basis, which consists of making compromises about their values to achieve immediate goals.
| MoneyMoz recommended article: Ready, Aim, Fire...Oops...Where's The Target? Everywhere you go on the Internet you find the words, "target market." What do they mean? What does it have to do with you? Well it has everything to do with your success in sales. Let me give you an example. A few weeks ago an online entrepreneur asked me to review a direct sales presentation for him. Let's call him "Joe". His product and service is excellent. Top quality and performance, excellent customer service and support. The product will produce desired results for any business advertising online. Your Baby's Ugly..and You've Got Bad Breath I've got good news and bad news. The good news is that 98% of businesses are small businesses. That bodes well for the entrepreneurial spirit that has made our nation great. The bad news is that 80%, that's right, four out of five new businesses will fail in their first five years. After years of building my own companies and consulting growing businesses, I've come to the realization that too many business owners can't see their business through an objective eye, which often leads to their demise. It takes an incredible amount of intense drive, determination and a strong ego to breathe life into a business and create products from scratch, but it's also that same ego that won't let a business owner be objective about what their business needs to succeed. The business is up and running at light-speed and management doesn't have the time or willingness to stand back and take a real look at what they have created. They are too close to the problems to see them. Just like a proud parent, they have spent sweat and time creating this “baby,” and they refuse to believe that it might be less than perfect. |
We Can’t Judge a Book by its Cover
Shein states that observing a group or an individual’s overt behavior does not always help one understand a group’s culture. Underlying values and assumptions drive an individual’s behavior and the way the person perceives and thinks about the world. These values can be viewed as ideologies, which remind this author of the observation that a theory is driven by value, space, and time. Books on theories advise that a researcher can understand and replicate theories with the space and time assumptions, but it is very difficult or impossible to manipulate the value variable.
It is these values or ideologies that lead to the three groups within an organization. The executives’ values can be viewed as primarily political (i.e., focused on the bottom line or the return on investment to please the share holders). The executive culture consists of the chief executive officer and his/her subordinates, who use the global occupational community as their point of reference (Schein, 1996). Most of their decisions are colored by political objectives. The engineer culture consists of designers and technocrats who use their professional association as their point of reference. Their decisions are motivated primarily, by bureaucratic ideologies. They carry out the mandates of the executives, for example: improve the bottom line. This may involve the design and automation of the processes without any concern for the number of employees that may be displaced. The operator culture is driven by their rational ideologies and past successes. They collaborate to meet production schedules, yet in many instances, they cannot understand the actions of the engineers and the executives. It is imperative to understand the contributions of each of the three factors to decision making.
Those who lead organizations should reflect on Schein’s observation–whether society is missing the point by primarily focusing on how engineers and executives learn. He claims that such a view is counterintuitive, given that the most appropriate way for the three cultures to understand one another is by understanding each other’s values. These values determine their behaviors. Fulmer and Wagner (1999) support this view in their discussion on leadership lessons—learning from the best.
Where to go from here?
| MoneyMoz recommended article: Data Loss - Can Your Company Survive? (Most Do Not) Data. Most people think it is a term relegated to the kingdom of geeks. However, in todays world your data is your life. Chances are every piece of data you might ever rely upon to make an important decision has been reduced to a digital format and resides somewhere on your computer's hard drive. Improved functionality and productivity are the benefits. However, on the flipside one wrong click, one nasty virus, one untimely power surge or unhappy employee and that data is gone forever! |
Organizational leaders in the US should realize that it is counterproductive to espouse teamwork and cooperation but reward only best-performing individuals. In this author’s view, this is a fundamental difference between the Japanese and American systems. The Japanese promote teamwork and reward the team.
Schein describes other paradoxes in organizations. For example, while information technology specialists see networking as a way of removing hierarchy, executives view hierarchy as a tool for enforcing control and coordination. Schein’s final suggestion is that organizational participants need to understand the inherent values upon which assumptions are based, understand one another, and address organizational problems from the same point of view for the sake of the organization’s survival. Recognizing that three cultural mind maps, mindsets, values, cultures and/or viewpoints exist within every organization is critical to resolving organizational issues and providing satisficing solutions. The ability of the three cultures to recognize and work with each other’s value-laden viewpoints can improve interpersonal communications, lift employee morale; improve productivity, and increase retention rate.
Covey, S. R. (1991). The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People. Simon & Schuster, New York, NY.
Fulmer, R. M., & Wagner, S. (1999). Leadership: Lessons from the best. Training and Development, 53(3), 28-34
Schein, E. H. (1996). Three cultures of management: The key to organizational learning. Sloan Management Review, 38(1), 9-20.
Dr. Odubiyi is the author of Blueprint for a Crooked House—a book that reflects on the factors that caused the collapse of a $10 billion global joint venture between AT&T and British Telecom. He is an associate professor of computer science at Bowie State University in Maryland. He was a Principal AI Researcher and R&D Manager at British Telecom North America/Concert Global Communications (USA).
http://www.blueprintforacrookedhouse.com
Keywords assigned to this article by MoneyMoz: Organizational cultures, executive, engineer, operator, values, assumptions, mindset, leadership
| MoneyMoz recommended article: 10 Common Direct Mail Mistakes and How to Avoid Them Successful direct mail does not need to be elaborate full color printing or creative design. The major factors contributing to a successful direct mail program are in the planning and implementing of the program. Avoid the following common blunders when developing your next mailing. 1. Ignoring the most important factor in direct mail success: the list. A Secret To Extraordinary Accomplishments I sat watching a documentary on U.S. Navy SEAL Team Training on the local exercise channel. It showed young men, mostly in their early 20's, enduring grueling ocean swims in near-freezing water. It showed these same young men forced to swim underwater (holding their breaths) until a major percentage of them passed out and had to be rescued by their instructors. It showed weeks of grueling training in which ordinary men are transformed into incredible machines with wills of steel and unshakable discipline. Sitting... transfixed, and marveling at what these young men were able to accomplish, I saw the one missing element that most online business people are missing. I saw an ingredient that if more of them harnessed it, they would be able to accomplish things "in their world" as magnificent. That one secret ingredient is teamwork. It was the group cohesiveness, and the fact that they were all working for a common purpose that allowed the SEAL Team trainees to accomplish what they would not normally be able to do. |